The films i will be focusing on is saving private ryan directed by steven spielberg (1998) and Hurt Locker directed by Kathryn Bigelow (2008. ) Saving private Ryan and Hurt locker are popular films, saving priavte ryan winning five Oscar for best director and best cinematogrpahy, best sound, best film editing, best effects, best picture. Also the director for hurt locker got best dirctor in 2010 and she was the only female.
From the opening of saving private ryan a use of a close up shot of a flag, this reflects the war patriotism of the film, being proud to be american, this positions the audience from a point of view of an american, as the audience is primarily american. The flag dominates the whole screen, the viewer can see it is desaturated this reflects how this film was based in the past, it also reflects a tinge of sadness,Showing how America isnt entirely whole. The way it waves in the wind reflects how america and the old man has a weakness from the events of this war. This is a low angle shot it makes it look heavnly suggesting this theme of death. non diegettic Music is being playing in major sets the sad tone by being slow and sombre. There is an enigma shot of feet we dont know who it is or what thy’re doing. A full orchestra of music starts to play as the old man walks towards the graves, he begins to cry sets up the tone of the film, sets the emotional agenda of the film from the outset.The camera tracks individual graves but also collectively, this reflects the film has for the death of soldiers, there is a beat of a snare drum when the camera stops on the individual graves as this sound is associated with war and patriotism. There is a close up shot of a french flag this gives context to the viewer indicating the characters are at a memorial in france. There is then the use of a graphic match when zooming into priavte ryans face, this misleads the viewer into thinking the captain is saving private ryan. There is a significance of setting it in present day this seeds misperception.
From the start of The beach landing scene, there are close ups of individual shots of mens faces showing their individual responses, some men are being sea sick this creates realism straight from the off the creates sympathy from the audience. As the men jump into the water these series of shots contrast with the chaos and makes the battle scene more powerful, and intensifies the violence, the audience would become desensitised if this scene was just one continuous battle. The muffled sound of underwater, is subject positioning the means the audience can hear what the character is hearing, this again creates realism. This bttele scene is slightly desaturated/He used such things as desaturated colour, which added to the dulled effect, which brought out the great tragedy and emotions in the film,By adding desaturation to the colour made the deaths seem more explicit, dark and deeply disturbing.In addition, the portrayal of the old newsreels allowed the audience to feel as if they were really there witnessing the events that were taking place in the 1940’s. The battle is overly surrounded with blood this creates realism and creates shock for the audience.The sanctity of life is presented to the audience with lack of meaning; death is illustrated throughout the opening scene as continuous and ordinary.The film questions the value of human life and what is valid to sacrifice for it. Sound is a key factor utilized by Spielberg to add realism.
Throughout the opening battle scene sounds of gunfire fill the air as the soldiers make their way towards the beach.The soundtrack consists of loud noises, for example, gun fire and exploding bombs.This feature reinforces various points in the scene where dialogue is barely audible, this particular layout is deliberately done so by Spielberg to emphasise to the audience how in reality but in particular, war the difficulties present were.Moreover, such small but vital details as these allow the audience to realise what it was truly like for the soldiers on the battle field.In this scene there is too a lot of confusion presented by the muting of sound, which is shown by the way that the soldiers react mainly because of shock and the fact that death cannot be escaped.
This rich use of depriving sound adds to the anxiety and anticipation of the scene, including the creation of realistic chaos typical of intense military conflict.
Spielberg applies innovative ways of sound placement and sound deprivation to help reveal character and reinforce central ideas and themes.
With the sound effects rising, such as the clanging of the bottle and the man being sick at the begging of the scene, makes the audience aware of the growing tension.
Furthermore, regarding sound, Captain Miller’s moment of confusion shows the idea of being shell-shocked.
As a bomb loudly crashes into the beach near where Captain Miller is walking.
This is greatly shown by the camera shaking to add more chaos and shows that there is more destruction in this scene.
Spielberg purposefully used a shaker to vibrate the camera to approximate the impact of explosions.
As Captain Miller is shocked, the cameras zoom into a close up of him in jerky slow motion.This creates the idea of helplessness.
Many films use blank munitions for sound effects that mimic gunfire, but on the contrary Spielberg instead used weapons with live rounds.
The realistic effects of the gunfire and the innovative placement of sounds create a rich cinematic experience, in order to present realism.
Moreover, Spielberg too applies the use of camera shots to present “Saving Private Ryan” in a realistic portrayal to the audience.
What’s more effective about the scene is where the soldiers are still on the engine boat, immediately after the boat door opens, chaos suddenly enters the film.
An unforeseen event occurs as German soldier’s fire their guns at the only recently arrived Americans.
At this part, Spielberg has the cameras set over the German soldiers’ shoulder with their identity concealed.
Such actions from Spielberg illustrate to the audience that no matter what nations participate in the war, nothing good can come from conflict, in this case war.
This long shot is also effective as it gives a clear view of their dominance and acts again humanity.
As the soldiers are suddenly taken down one by one with the sound of the rushing bullets, the handheld cameras are immediately brought out.
They follow the few remaining survivors into the sea.
As the camera drifts above and below the water, chaos suddenly emerges as if the individuals present were drowning.
This is too presented because the sound is muted as if it were the soldiers own lack of senses not working in his time of turbulence.
Spielberg uses haphazard cameras to follow the soldiers into the battle.
It has the audience directly feel as if they’re apart of the action because they can view and experience the battle themselves.
This allows the audience to feel more involved in the whole experience as if they’re following the soldiers, and taking part in the war themselves.
There are a series of long shots of the soldiers but soon changes to the point of view of the Germans once more.
This is a great technique as other conventional films only demonstrate the battles being from one-side but using an over-the-shoulder shot for the point of view makes the Germans appear more powerful as they are looking down upon the soldiers and therefore have an advantage.
In this scene we can also see that the most common emotion felt is confusion as many soldiers appear to be lost and traumatized because of the terror they witness.
The second section of the opening scene was in instant chaos.
As the camera turns away from the iron hedgehog and set to a close up of Captain Miller nerves, which is shown through his shaking hands.
Also as the camera zooms away from the single image of Captain Miller, the director emphasises how significant his presence is in the war.
When the men are shot down underwater there are various close up shots of the wounded, to try and encourage sympathy for the suffering war veterans went through for society as a whole.
This is made realistic by Spielberg hiring actual amputees being casted into the film.
In “Saving Private Ryan” the camera focuses on capturing key moments of torment.
The film consists of some men jump over the sides of the boat to avoid gun fire, only to be drowned by their own packs
The air is heavily filled with smoke and the sound of screams
Image after image of unforgettable carnage is displayed, and at one point, everything seems to slow down, and the sounds grow distant, as though time were standing still
Overall Spielberg has clearly made several attempts to illustrate the film “Saving Private Ryan” in a realistic manner, in which I believe he has succeeded.
Moreover, the soldiers were in authentic uniforms and weighted down with heavy guns and seen shaking in fear, praying, and throwing up
Soldiers that survived that day to tell their story helped provide details about what they experienced.
The images shown were extremely shocking and brutal but showed the audience what fighting in war was really like and how several soldiers suffered and died
“Realism in film is achieved through artiface”- Bazin
Robert Capa- photographer: Level of cultural recognition
Action reaction- Germans POV vs Americans POV
Editing: long duration shots
No dramatic irony- we don’t know anything that the people on the beach know
Tom Hanks- non matrixed index: shaking hands
Dialogue before bomb sounds- individual shots- generates sympathy
Long slow build up however all of the men being shot in the boat happens suddenly- presents how the war is unexpected/ shocking
German soldier’s representation: silhouettes/ gunning down the soldiers that have already fixed us with some empathy
Blood on screen= more real
Start to associate with a character as they start to speak/ they’re being saved however they die
Repetition of German POV
All the light in the middle- dark around the edges- makes it seem like it’s our perspective
Repetition of subjective positioning